New Orleans Archdiocese Coopts NOPD

by: ryan

Tue Jan 06, 2009 at 13:34:35 PM CST


I woke up this morning to the news that the New Orleans Police Department arrested two Catholic parishioners holding a peaceful vigil protesting the closure of Our Lady of Good Counsel here in New Orleans. It amazes me that the NOPD finds the time and effort to arrest two Catholic parishioners attempting civil disobedience against the leader of their church here in New Orleans, but can't for the life of them correctly fight the real crimes happening here in New Orleans. (Hat Tip to Oyster for the link)

On top of that, Archbishop Hughes ought to take a good look at what's happening up in Massachusetts, as his colleague up there - Cardinal O'Malley - has permitted the parishioners to keep vigil for 1,534 days without resorting to having police officers arrest the peaceful protestors.

Perhaps Cardinal O'Malley has a little more of that old fashioned shame that the Catholics instill in their parishioners oh so well, as the church, where the vigil has lasted more than four years, occupies prime real coastal real estate outside Boston. Might that be the reason that Our Lady of Good Counsel is slated for closure here in New Orleans? After all, it is a "Gothic-style brick building [that] is arguably the most precious jewel in the crown known as New Orleans's graceful Garden District." It's also a National Historic Landmark, which will help protect the building itself, but won't force the Archdiocese to keep it as a church.

Might this just be a money-grab by the Archdiocese? If so, how utterly shameless of the Archbishop to employ the New Orleans Police Department in his quest to make a quick buck.

If I was a good church-going Catholic, I'd organize a campaign to withhold the donations until the Archdiocese gets the point. Make do without the cell phones and whatever other luxuries y'all have before shuttering parishes. Y'all did take a vow of poverty, did you not?

ryan :: New Orleans Archdiocese Coopts NOPD
Tags: , , , , , , (All Tags)
Print Friendly View Send As Email
parish (0.00 / 1)
Great post, Ryan.

I made some similar points this evening in a post, before checking my reader. I guess we were on the same wavelength regarding the two articles. I went back and inserted a link to this post in mine, because it worked so well.


Playing devil's advocate (0.00 / 0)
Much of my feelings on this issue depend on the answer of the question "Who actually owns the property?".

However, assuming the Church owns the property, why shouldn't the NOPD be used to remove trespassers? Because of the high amount of crime in New Orleans, are you suggesting that if someone is on my property who is unwelcome that I should not call the cops?

And since I am Jewish I admit I am not an expert on the Catholic Church. However, wouldn't "good church-going Catholic[s]" change churches if that is what the church required of them?  


Sure, I'll play (0.00 / 0)
"why shouldn't the NOPD be used to remove trespassers?"

Because the optics are incredibly bad.

"Because of the high amount of crime in New Orleans, are you suggesting that if someone is on my property who is unwelcome that I should not call the cops?"

Uhh, that's stretching it. These "someones" comprise the church in question. They are not strangers trespassing with potential criminal intent; this is a protest/vigil to save historic parishes in vibrant neighborhoods.  

"wouldn't 'good church-going Catholic[s]' change churches if that is what the church required of them?"

Yes. And as a Protestant I secretly enjoy the irony of this "protest".  And I appreciate your devil's advocacy, too.



[ Parent ]
ADVERTISING


Help keep the Kingfish going with donations.







WEB 2.0

Subscribe to the Kingfish Feed!


MENU

New here? Join us!

Login Username:

Password:



Forgot username/password? About The Daily Kingfish


NATIONAL BLOGS
DailyKos
Media Matters
MyDD
OpenLeft
Senate Guru
Street Prophets
SwingState
Talking Points Memo
Vote Vets Blog - Vet Voice
The Washington Independent

LOUISIANA BLOGS
Acadiana and SW LA Dems
Adrastos
Ashley Morris
Bayou St. John David
CenLamar
Danger Blond
Da Po' Blog
democrat2democrat
Fix The Pumps
Gentilly Girl
The Head Pelican
In The Loop
Jindal Is Bad
JoefromLA
Katrinacrat
Lafayette Pro Fiber Blog
Levees Not War
Library Chronicles
Not Right about Anything
ProLa
T. Wong's Gazette
Suspect Device
Yat Pundit
Your Right Hand Thief

Know Louisiana blogs that ought to be here?

Contact me

DEMS, ALLIES, ORGS
Calcasieu Parish Democrats
CODOFIL
Congresspedia
DCCC - The Stakeholder F.F.L.I.C.
Louisiana Democrats
LA House Democratic Caucus
La Roots
Lafayette Democrats
L.E.A.N.
L.L.B.C.
Orleans Democrats
St. Tammany Democrats
Toxic Trailers
Voter Watch

NEWS SITES
Advocate
225 Weekly
Gambit Weekly
Jim Brown
Lafayette Independent
Times Picayune
The Reduct Box

Know Louisiana news sites that ought to be here?

Contact me


MEDIA

Steering John N. Kennedy

Mary Landrieu: Fighter

Mary Landrieu's 2nd Video Diary

LA GOP Chair Praises Landrieu

Don Cazayoux: "Tips"


Don Cazayoux: "Middle Class"

Laurinda Calongne: AWOL for 7 Years

Mary Landrieu's 1st Video Diary

McCain = Bush

Don Cazayoux: "Not Easy"